Peace at Battle Mountain and Misplaced Priorities

As indicated in prior blogs, each of the Arthur Stone novels (Marshland [1]and Peace at Battle Mountain[2]) involves an economic and legal problem, murder, and engagement with spiritual realities. In Peace at Battle Mountain, the spiritual reality is our human problem with what St. Augustine called “disordered love.” We love as primary things that are secondary and as secondary things that are primary. A good deal of the suffering and distortion of human flourishing we encounter in our lives and the lives of others involves just this problem.

In Peace at Battle Mountain, the aging and now retired managing partner of Winchester & Wells talks to the now middle-aged Arthur Stone about this problem:

Patrick decided to get to the point.

            “Arthur, you know that, for years and years, I was all in at the firm. I thought we were building something meaningful. I also felt I was doing something important and building an important reputation. I rarely worked less than seventy hours a week. For many years, I never even took a vacation. The law was my life.

            “I realized I was mistaken when Jeanie got sick so soon after I retired. The firm was important, but Jeanie and the children were more important. She rarely complained, but everything we planned to do in retirement never happened. I had my priorities mixed up.

            “You have been far more successful than I ever was. You are known throughout the nation. Most people think you are Texas’s best litigator and corporate attorney. It makes me proud every time I hear your name. But you are fifty now. Soon, your children will be grown. As you have said, the law is changing, and there is every possibility that what we know as Winchester & Wells might not survive the changes. I would hate to see you at seventy alone and thinking, It was not worth it.

            “I am an Irish Catholic. I still go to mass once a week. Our priest uses a message from St. Augustine in sermons at least once a year. It is about disordered love. Augustine felt that human beings love as primary, what are secondary things like power, success, possessions, and pleasure. In the process, we make love for God and other people secondary. Most of the world’s problems come from loving the wrong things too much or the right things too little

            “I would hate for you to chase crown of victory after crown of victory for another twenty years or so, only to end up alone and empty. Plenty of men and women do. I did. Your family is more important than winning another case or even 100 other cases. You are a wealthy man and do not need to show how good you are to anyone ever again. Right now, your family needs you. [3]

In his great work, “On Christian Doctrine,” St. Augustine puts it this way:

Living a just and holy life requires one to be capable of an objective and impartial evaluation of things: to love things in the right order so that you do not love what is not to be loved or fail to love what is to be loved or have a greater love for what should be loved less, or an equal love for things that should be loved less or more, or a lesser or greater love for things that should be loved equally. [4]

In On Christian Doctrine, Augustine bases his entire ethical theory on the Great Commandment, “You shall love the Lord that God with all your heart, and all the soul, and all your mind and your neighbor as your self (Matthew 22: 35-40; Mark 12:28-31; Luke 10: 25-28).In other words, a Christian is to order his or her affections toward God first and others second. Our love toward our neighbor is just a part of our love for God, now shown to God’s creation and all his creatures. Other human beings are part of that creation and art to be loved in the same way that God loved them and in Christ gave his life for them.

The duty to love others cannot be divorced entirely from our responsibility to communicate the gospel. Part of loving another person is to bring them into a vital connection with that God who is love and who loves his creation and every creature. This part of love is captured in the Great Commission. God does not ask Christians to share their faith out of ego, narcissism, or a desire for power. God desires Christians to share their faith because God is love and desires his creation and creatures to live with love for God and others.

One way we can distort our lives is by loving human beings, who ought to be loved for their own sake, as objects of our desire. This is one of the problems in Peace Battle Mountain. In particular, Lance DuFort is incapable of loving others except as vehicles for his own ambitions and desires. Others in the book suffer the same fate.

In the passage quoted above, Arthur Stone meets with his mentor, Patrick Armbruster, who gives him advice about organizing his love for his wife and family. Patrick is aware that human beings can worship their own work and accomplishments. He is fearful that Arthur is falling into this trap of distorted love.

Building a business, a church, or a nonprofit organization can be demanding. Those who undertake such an effort must love the organization that they are creating. As anyone who has had a career knows, it is easy to give a job or organization a kind of love that one should reserve for God and others. In particular, one’s family. I would say that I was guilty of this during my professional career. It is easy to love ourselves in our own ambitions to the exclusion of our love for others and God.

Peace at Battle Mountain is primarily about love. It is about distorted lives and the struggle we humans must engage in to re-order our loves properly. As pointed out, we find it easy to love ourselves. We find it harder to love God and others. We humans are naturally selfish, and the result of our natural selfishness is that we need to have these loves re-ordered by grace. It is a slow process. It doesn’t happen in an hour or a day. There may be a moment in which we sense that we are committed to re-ordering our loves and even making some progress and re-ordering our loves—but that reordering will take the rest of our lives.

Copyright 2024, G. Christopher Scruggs, All Rights Reserved

[1] Alystair West, Marshland (Bloomington, IN: Westbow Press, 2023). The book is available on Amazon.

[2] Alystair West, Peace at Battle Mountain (Hunt, TX: Quansus, 2024). The book is available on Amazon.

[3] Peace at Battle Mountain, 171-172.

[4] St. Augustine, “On Christian Doctrine” Chapter 27 in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers 1st Series Vol, 2 (Grand Rapids MI: Hendrickson, 1994).