Freedom of Religion 4: Approaches to Church/State Relationships

I hope this will be my last week on freedom of religion, so I can finish this series of blogs on the First Amendment before mid-November. There are basically three different ways in which legal scholars and the courts approach the issue of establishment of religion.

  1. The first of these is called the “Strict Separation” theory;
  2. The second is called the “Religious Neutrality” theory, that is that the government should be neutral as regards religious matters; and
  3. The third is the “Accommodation” theory, which holds that, in a free society, the church, the state, and different religious groups must accommodate one another.[1]

In this blog, I’ll cover these three theories, each with its proponents.

Strict Separation Theory

The first of these theories is sometimes referred to as strict separation. I introduced this theory last week, noting that the term “wall of separation” was introduced into constitutional theory by Justice Black.[2] One of the problems with having a flare for the memorable phrase, as Jefferson did, is that the phrase can take on a kind of legitimacy it was never intended to have. That’s exactly what’s happened to the wall of separation theory. In the abstract, it sounded pretty good. In reality it wouldn’t work. From the very beginning, the court has had to deal with the problem of how to balance the various interest at stake where religion comes into contact with the state.

In my opinion, and it’s only an opinion, one problem with the separation theory today is that secular humanism, which functions as a kind of religion for many people, is not thought to be subject to the wall of separation. In fact, it forms the basis of most public education, a great deal of public policy, and is the subject of a great deal of conflict in our society. It simply is not possible to protect, for example, the public school systems in the way we traditionally did because of this development. What is occurred is the gradual separation of religious people of all kinds of religious traditions from public education. I’m not smart enough to know how this can be healed, but one can easily see. It has not been a good thing for our national cohesion, nor has been a good thing for the education of our young people.

Neutrality Theory

The second approach to the relationship between the state and religious groups is referred to as neutrality theory. This theory basically tries to take the position that governments cannot favor one religion or secularism over any other position. This was the position that New Jersey was trying to take when it allowed all religious groups to be covered by the payment system for transportation. They were trying to be neutral. The case of Lynch v. Donnelly can be used to illustrate this approach. Lynch v. Donnelly, 465 U.S. 668 (1984), held that the inclusion of a crèche (nativity scene) in a city’s annual Christmas display does not violate the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause.[3] In a 5-4 decision, the court held that the inclusion of a nativity scene in a public place together with other religious and executor displays what did not amount to an establishment of religion. In response to this approach, and because of the closeness between Hanukkah and Christmas, many public areas contain a variety of religious symbols, including Muslim symbols, in Christmas displays.

 The court based its reasoned that the purpose of the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses of the First Amendment was to prevent, as far as practical, the intrusion of religious groups and the secular state into the areas largely the province of the other.  At the same time, however, the Court recognized that “total separation is not possible in an absolute sense. Some relationship between government and religious organizations is inevitable.” Thus, in Establishment Clause cases, the Court is generally called to reconcile the inescapable tension between the objective of preventing unnecessary intrusion of either the church or the state upon the other, and the reality that, as the Court has so often noted, total separation of the two is not possible. [4]

In my view, the court was wise in taking the approach it took. However, everyone feels about the specifics of the case, it can be seen that in principle the court is recognizing that a complete separation of religion and public life is neither possible nor desirable. In fact, it’s inevitable that people who are of different religious face living in close proximity to one another, but will be in touch with religious views of other people, and also the views of the state.

In most cities, many practices, including the practice of including Chris scenes, Hanukkah, candles, and other religious displays as part of Christmas decorations is not so much the advocation of a religious view, or the states attempt to enforce a religious view, as it is a reflection of the fact that we are all citizens of the same community inhabiting the same community space. And such, even if we are not, for example Jewish, we can appreciate the Jewish holiday and its importance for Jewish people. The same as true of other religious groups.

First amendment was not designed to eliminate religious observance from public life,; it was designed to prohibit the secular state from enforcing one particular view or p(increasingly important) no religious view at all. An observation that I think is important: second or humanism is not a religion. It’s the absence of religion. It’s a religion of no religion at all. Sandra Day O’Connor, in her concurring opinion in Lynchfield Donnelly makes this precise point when she says:

The Establishment Clause prohibits government from making adherence to a religion relevant in any way to a person’s standing in the political community. Government can run afoul of that prohibition in two principal ways. One is excessive … entanglement with religious institutions, which may interfere with the independence of the institutions, give the institutions access to government or governmental powers not fully shared by non-adherents of the religion, and foster the creation of political constituencies defined along religious lines. …The second and more direct infringement is government endorsement or disapproval of religion. Endorsement sends a message to non-adherents that they are outsiders, not full members of the political community, and an accompanying message to adherents that they are insiders, favored members of the political community. Disapproval sends the opposite message…[5]

The best way to understand justice O’Connors’ concurring opinion is that the establishment clause cannot be used as a cloak by a secular state to prohibit religious views of any kind.

Accommodation Theory

This leads to a discussion of the third and last approach: Accommodation. The final approach is sometimes called and accommodative approach to First Amendment rights. Under this approach, the Court interprets the Establishment Clause understanding the importance of religion in society and overturns state actions only if it establishes a religion, courses participation in some way, or favors one religious view over another. Justice Kennedy has been an example of the way this approach might work.

In Lee v. Weisman, the Court ruled that having the school principal select a clergyman to deliver a prayer at graduation violated the Establishment Clause’s prohibition against state involvement in establishing religion.[6]  This case involved the practice of several other public middle and high school principals in Providence, Rhode Island, Robert E. Lee, a middle school principal, of inviting clergy to speak at graduation ceremonies Daniel Weisman’s daughter, Deborah, was among the graduates. Hoping to stop the rabbi from speaking at his daughter’s graduation, Weisman sought a temporary restraining order in District Court – but was denied. After the ceremony, where prayers were recited, Weisman filed for a permanent injunction barring Lee and other Providence public school officials from inviting clergy to deliver invocations and benedictions at their schools’ ceremonies.

The Prayer was as follows:

“0 God, we are grateful to You for having endowed us with the capacity for learning which we have celebrated on this joyous commencement.

“Happy families give thanks for seeing their children achieve an important milestone. Send Your blessings upon the teachers and administrators who helped prepare them.

“The graduates now need strength and guidance for the future, help them to understand that we are not complete with academic knowledge alone. We must each strive to fulfill what You require of us all: To do justly, to love mercy, to walk humbly.

“We give thanks to You, Lord, for keeping us alive, sustaining us and allowing us to reach this special, happy occasion.

When the Court of Appeals affirmed a District Court ruling against the schools, Lee appealed to the Supreme Court. At least one scholar believes that Justice Kennedy, writing for the majority, articulated an approach close to this.[7]In fact, it is justice Scalia, writing in dissent, who articulates what an accommodative approach might look like in practice, when he says:

…the Establishment Clause must be construed in light of the “[g]overnment policies of accommodation, acknowledgment, and support for religion [that] are an accepted part of our political and cultural heritage.” That opinion affirmed that “the meaning of the Clause is to be determined by reference to historical practices and understandings.” It said that “[a] test for implementing the protections of the Establishment Clause that, if applied with consistency, would invalidate longstanding traditions cannot be a proper reading of the Clause.”[8]

I hope to write a longer blog on this case and other cases along these lines. The point is simple: the First Amendment was never designed to eliminate religious practices that were part of our cultural heritage from public life. This is an invention of the modern secular state and its attempt to create schools, public spaces, and even offices of government to which religion is excluded in its entirety. This would eliminate vast areas of our cultural heritage.

The most obvious example is the removal of the Ten Commandments from public buildings. Displaying the Ten Commandments in public buildings doesn’t establish either the Jewish or the Christian religion in America. Rather, it reflects that our religious tradition begins with Jewish law. I know very few people of any religious heritage who believe it would be wise to institute Jewish law in detail. We do, however, recognize its importance in our history and legal tradition. Other elements have played an equally important role. For example, Roman law and English common law have had a much more significant and pervasive influence on how the American legal system works. The point is that we should honor the roots of our constitutional heritage. That doesn’t mean we’re establishing a particular religion or endorsing a particular view of our legal history.[9]

Levy Wiseman shows how “accommodation theory” can mask hostility toward religion in public life. I included the prayer at the beginning of this section to show that it is not specifically Christian or religious and refers only to God. It does not identify God as Jewish or Christian. Moreover, nothing in the prayer would offend a reasonable person. The prayer simply expresses the parents’ and graduates’ gratitude for the graduation, their joy in the occasion, and their thankfulness for being able to attend. It seems likely that people of nearly any religion—or no religion at all—would share these feelings at graduation. If this prayer violates the Establishment Clause, it is difficult to imagine any former religious observance that would not violate the First Amendment.

Conclusion

I realize I’ll need to discuss specific cases in this blog series at some point, but I’d like to save that for later. For now, I’m keeping this as a simple introduction—and I’m ready to move on to another area of interest! Next week, I’ll be talking about the Right of Public Assembly.

In the meantime, I hope readers of every persuasion will see why I believe our society can prosper when we embrace a view of the church-and-state relationship that recognizes how closely our religious perspectives and public life are connected. In a multi-religious society, that means making room for people to express religious views we may personally disagree with. For example, our Muslim neighbors may come from countries with Sharia law and may hold different views from ours on what should be written into law. They should still be free to share those views in public life. That doesn’t mean those views will become law; it simply means they have the right to argue that Sharia law has something to offer our legal system. This is why I have been arguing for what I call “A Tolerant Public Square,” in which religious views are considered alongside other views in the search for a just society.

Copyright 2026, G,,Christopher Scruggs, All Rights Reserved

[1] I need to give praise where praise is due for the work of Erwin Chemerinsky, in his book Constitutional Law: Principles and Policies 3rdedition (New York NY: Aspen Publishers, 2006).  It is intended as a comprehensive introduction to the Constitution for serious students. I do not necessarily agree with Chermerinisky’s conclusions, but have found his work thought provoking. In particularly, as will be seen below, I believe the Accommodation Theory in practice is a flawed approach.

[2] Everson v. Board of Education of the Township of Ewing, 330 U. S. 1 (1947).

[3] Lynch v. Donnelly, 465 U.S. 668 (1984).

[4] Id.

[5] Id. Internal citations have been admitted for readability. I also corrected non-adherence in the way we would normally spell it.

[6] Lee v. Weisman, 505 U.S. 577 (1992).

[7] Constitutional Law: Principles and Policies.

[8] Id.

[9] This is an area that is currently in litigation. The court entered this legal quagmire, which has since become the subject of many cases seeking ways to continue recognizing our legal heritage. It’s too early to tell how the cases will turn out; however, one of the most important cases currently on appeal involves a Texas law (Nathan v. Alamo). I’ll try to read it, figure out what it means, and report later.

Freedom of Religion 3: The Relationship Between the Church and the State

Prior to the American Revolution, American churches enjoyed a remarkable degree of freedom by the standards of Europe at the time. Pastors from the pulpit criticized governments, policies, and other matters. They defended their own theological positions, often using extremel language in criticizing opponents. In particular, many Protestant groups criticized the Roman Catholic Church.

During the American Revolution, pastors played an important role, and many served in Washington’s army. As an example, in 1774, two full years before the Declaration of Independence, the Provincial Congress of Massachusetts stated:

“…we cannot but acknowledge the goodness of Heaven in constantly supplying us with preachers of the Gospel whose concern has been the temporal and spiritual happiness of this people…and do therefore recommend…that they assist us in avoiding that dreadful slavery with which we are now threatened…” [1]

Jonas Clark, Pastor of the Church in Lexington, Massachusetts, was a case in point.  He actively authored many papers recording the town’s position on liberty.  Without him, there may have been no “shot heard round the world!” [2]

The Danbury Letter.

As mentioned last week, when North Americans gained their freedom from Great Britain, during the time of the Articles of Confederation and the adoption of the Constitution, many feared that various states might adopt a “State Religion,” limiting the religious freedom of other groups. The First Amendment responded to that fear.

In 1801, the Danbury Baptist Association in Connecticut wrote a letter to Thomas Jefferson, complementing him on his election to the president presidency. In the letter, they expressed their views of the importance of religious liberty to the nation. In the letter, they expressed their hope that Jefferson would express his views as to the importance of religious liberty to the nation.[3] Jefferson, who was himself a deist, responded to the letter defending religious liberty:

Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should “make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,” thus building a wall of separation between Church & State. Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore to man all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties. [4]

Several points in this response stand out immediately. Jefferson speaks of “natural rights.” Jefferson aligns with the Enlightenment version of the natural law tradition, believing that human nature yields certain rights applicable to all people. This is why, in the Declaration of Independence, he speaks of human beings as endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights.[5]  Jefferson strongly believed that freedom of religion and speech were inherent natural rights belonging to all people, and that the government should not interfere with them. Second, this means the government should not suppress matters of faith and worship or the public expression of views. Third, the government still has the authority to enact laws and ensure people follow them for the benefit of society.

The Purpose of the Phrase “Wall of Separation”

The phrase Wall of Separation” used by Jefferson in his reply has been the source of much controversy. It is important to read carefully what Jefferson said and intended. Jeffersons reply says:

Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should “make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,” thus building a wall of separation between Church & State.[6]

Jefferson clearly states that “should make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, thus building a wall of separation between Church & State.” In other words, the phrase “a wall of separation” was not intended to mean that religion should not influence opinions on issues. The “Wall of Separation” protects religious people’s freedom to practice their religion. In our society, the phrase is too often used to deny religious people the right to speak about their views in public life. Unfortunately, in the hands of modern courts, it has come not to protect religious profession and expression but to limit them. How that came about is a sad and complicated story.

Jefferson and John Adams exchanged a series of letters in their later years (primarily from 1812 to 1826), after reconciling their friendship following years of political estrangement. While their correspondence covered a wide range of philosophical, historical, and personal topics, they also touched on the U.S. Constitution’s role and its implications for future generations, often in the context of governance, aristocracy, and the passage of time.

Jefferson tended to emphasize generational sovereignty—the idea that one generation should not impose binding obligations on the next—echoing his earlier views expressed to James Madison in 1789. Adams, by contrast, stressed institutional continuity, learning from history, and safeguarding their era’s fragile achievements against future threats. Interestingly, both agreed that the free exercise of the Christian religion in particular was important to the success of what has been called “The American Experiment” in free self-government.[7]

In his first Inaugural Address, Jefferson urged his fellow countrymen to put the bitterness of the past campaign to rest and protect the hard-won gains of the American Revolution. He urged a return to reason and the avoidance of political intolerance, which is just as dangerous as religious intolerance. He urges an enlightened religious participation in politics with these words:

Let us, then, with courage and confidence pursue our own Federal and Republican principles, our attachment to union and representative government. Kindly separated by nature and a wide ocean from the exterminating havoc of one quarter of the globe; too high-minded to endure the degradations of the others; possessing a chosen country, with room enough for our descendants to the thousandth and thousandth generation; entertaining a due sense of our equal right to the use of our own faculties, to the acquisitions of our own industry, to honor and confidence from our fellow-citizens, resulting not from birth, but from our actions and their sense of them; enlightened by a benign religion, professed, indeed, and practiced in various forms, yet all of them inculcating honesty, truth, temperance, gratitude, and the love of man; acknowledging and adoring an overruling Providence, which by all its dispensations proves that it delights in the happiness of man here and his greater happiness hereafter — with all these blessings, what more is necessary to make us a happy and a prosperous people?[8]

Jefferson in his inaugural address was not advocating a purely secular society, but a society characterized by a virtuous and tolerant citizenry.

In a famous letter to Jefferson, Adams proclaimed:

The general Principles, on which the Fathers Atchieved Independence, were the only Principles in which, that beautiful Assembly of young Gentlemen9 could Unite, and these Principles only could be intended by them in their Address, or by me in my Answer. And what were these general Principles? I answer, the general Principles of Christianity, in which all those Sects were United: And the general Principles of English and American Liberty, in which all those young Men United, and which had United all Parties in America, in Majorities Sufficient to assert and maintain her Independence.[9]

Once again, in this letter, Adams, a deist, was recognizing the importance of faith and moral principles in a seccessful democratic republic.

I’ve taken time to introduce the relationship between church and state, hoping to make the following principle clear: The First Amendment was not designed to protect the state from the church or to shield non-religious people from hearing religious opinions. Rather, it was intended to protect religious people’s right to make their faith known in public life. It was not meant to prevent churches from expressing their views, even when addressing political issues. It was intended to protect that right.

The Wall of Separation in Modern Jurisprudence.

The wall-of-separation argument entered post-World War II Supreme Court jurisprudence in Everson v. Board of Education of the Township of Ewing.[10] In this case, a New Jersey law authorized local school boards to reimburse the costs of transportation to and from schools, including private schools. Nearly all the private schools that benefited from this law were Catholic schools. Everson, a taxpayer in Ewing Township, filed a lawsuit alleging that this indirect aid to religion violated both the New Jersey state constitution and the First Amendment. After losing in state courts, Everson appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court on purely federal constitutional grounds.

Justice Black, writing for the majority, upheld the law and concluded that the division between church and state had not been breached, stating, “The First Amendment has erected a wall between church and state. That wall must be kept high and impregnable. We could not approve the slightest breach. New Jersey has not breached it here.” In reaching that conclusion, the court noted that the statute required reimbursements to be given without regard to religious affiliation to any religious group that qualified for the assistance. In other words, it did not establish your religion.

The majority decision in Ewing met with vigorous, well-reasoned opposition. Justice Jackson focused on the nature of parochial schools and the religious education students inevitably receive there. He dodges the fact that the New Jersey Statute specifically did not establish any religion (the constitutional barrier) and treated all religions equally. Justice Rutledge, in his dissent, makes the point that I want to bring my own analysis upon:

The Amendment’s purpose was not to strike merely at the official establishment of a single sect, creed or religion, outlawing only a formal relation such as had prevailed in England and some of the colonies. Necessarily, it was to uproot all such relationships. But the object was broader than separating church and state in this narrow sense. It was to create a complete and permanent separation of the spheres of religious activity and civil authority by comprehensively forbidding every form of public aid or support for religion. [11]

The phrase “It was to create a complete and permanent separation of the spheres of religious activity and civil authority by comprehensively forbidding every form of public aid or support for religion.” This is not what either the Constitution or the relevant textual history would indicate. This is the importation of what political philosophers call “Sphere Sovereignty” into the Constitution.[12]

Let us remind ourselves of the exact wording of the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;….” There was nothing in the New Jersey Law that forced anyone to worship in any particular way or to refrain from worshiping in any way. It neither established a religion nor forced any one to cease worshiping their God. This is the only “Wall of Separation” contained in the Constitution.

At this point, I want to suggest a different way of looking at the issue of the relationship of Church and State and interpreting the First Amendment. The purpose of the Amendment was simply to prohibit the adoption of a mandatory state religion. The reason was not to create a Wall of Separation but to protect religious people and groups from government interference in their religion. There was no notion of protecting the sovereignty of a secular state or of establishing a “Naked Public Square” walled off from interference by religious groups.

In fact, there can be no “Wall of Separation,” which in recent years the majority of the Court has recognized, or should there. Citizens are embodied persons, mind body, soul and spirit, and their religious views and their political views are not separate domains. What is needed is a “Public Sphere of Tolerance” religious people, their moral, political and other views, a Public Sphere of Tolerance into which the government cannot “establish a religion, or prohibit the free exercise thereof.” In this Public Square of Tolerance, all views are weighed and considered as part of the great public project of creating a harmonious and just society.

More to come.

Copyright 2026, G. Christopher Scruggs, All Rights Reserved

[1] Verna M. Hall, Christian History of the American Revolution, (Chesapeake VA: Foundation for American Christian Education, 1976), 402 found at https://heritageministriesky.com/2019/01/17/pastors-inspired-the-american-revolution-3/ (downloaded March 7, 2024).

[2] Id.

[3] Letter of the Danbury Baptist Association to Thomas Jefferson, (after October 7, 1802).

[4] Thomas Jefferson, “Jefferson’s Letter to the Danbury Baptists The Final Letter as Sent” (January 1, 1802), downloaded from the Library of Congress, https://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/9806/danpre.html (March 7, 2024).

[5] Declaration of Independence (US 1776).

[6] Danbury Letter, Footnote 4 above.

[7] In his first Inaugural Address, George Washington referred to the preservation of the “republican model of government” as an “experiment entrusted to the hands of the American people”, and later remarked that it was the “last great experiment for promoting human happiness”. George Washington, First Inaugural Address (1789).

[8] Thomas Jefferson, First Inaugural Address (March 4, 1801. He concludes, “Relying, then, on the patronage of your good will, I advance with obedience to the work, ready to retire from it whenever you become sensible how much better choice it is in your power to make. And may that Infinite Power which rules the destinies of the universe lead our councils to what is best, and give them a favorable issue for your peace and prosperity.” Neither Adams nor Jefferson believed that religion should be banished from the public square.

[9] Letter from John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, June 28, 1813). Both Adams and Jefferson were deists, not committed to a narrow version of the Christian faith or its implications for public life.

[10] Everson v. Board of Education of the Township of Ewing, 330 U. S. 1 (1947).

[11] Id, 32-33.

[12] “Sphere Sovereignty is a term used by Abraham Kuyper (1837-1920). Kuyper was an influential Calvinist thinker and also the Prime Minister of the Netherlands for a time. In 1880 he gave an important address in which he suggested a mechanical order of sovereignty in which each sphere, secular and sacred had an independent sovereignty which related to each other in a mechanical way. “Now in all of these spheres or circles the cogwheels engage one another, and it is precisely because of the mutual interaction of these spheres that there is an emergence of that rich, many-sided, multi-formed human life; but in that life there is also the danger that one sphere may encroach upon the neighboring sphere; thus causing a wheel to jerk and to break cog upon cog, and interfering with the progress of the whole.” This is not the place to discuss Kuyper’s theory in detail, which I promise to do, God willing at a later time. Abraham Kuyper, “Sphere Sovereignty” tr, George Kamps (Public address delivered at the inauguration of the Free University, Oct. 20, 1880). It goes witboug saying that Kuyper has internalized the common mechanical view of reality that has its limited application in both science and law.

Five Freedoms 2: Our Religious Rights

Last week’s post began a series on the First Amendment, and I’m excited to continue this week by sharing more about it, focusing on religious liberty. When I first started writing these constitutional blogs years ago, I wanted to explore the First Amendment and the challenges society faces with both freedom of speech and religion. Throughout the 20thcentury, people strongly supported protecting these rights, especially through popular culture. However, as we moved into the late 20th and early 21st centuries, we’ve seen attacks on religious freedom from both the left and the right. It’s quite surprising and concerning because it points to a breakdown in our national political culture. That’s why I believe this series of blogs matters, and I wish I could do an even better job explaining how vital these issues are to all of us.

Religious Freedom and the First Amendment

The First Amendment begins by protecting religious rights: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;….”[1] On its face, the First Amendment provides two mechanisms by which religious freedom is to be protected:

  1. Congress cannot establish a religion
  2. Congress cannot create laws that would prohibit the free exercise of religion.

Today, because of the 14th Amendment, states are similarly prohibited from establishing a religion or prohibiting the free exercise of religion.[2] Taken together, these two provisions prevent government from prohibiting a particular religious view or establishing one as normative within its jurisdiction.

In recent years, the Court has made many decisions on the Establishment Clause in various areas, including religious education. Applying the amendment today is difficult because of the vast social differences between America today and America in 1789. In 1789, the United States was mostly Protestant Christian. There were, however, Catholic minorities and, in Maryland, a Catholic majority. Finally, there was a Jewish minority that no less a person than George Washington indicated was protected by the First Amendment, and that their rights should be protected by the government.[3]

With the emergence of the United States as a world power and the center of the global economy, citizens from nearly every nation in the world have moved to the United States, resulting in the presence of various religious minorities within the United States. In addition, the emergence of a form of secularism that takes the form of a religious devotion in many people has created yet another group that claims a religious right to practice the religion of second or humanism. Finally, there are even groups that worship Satan and other entities that claim the right to their religious freedom. It should be obvious that it’s unlikely the founders even thought about these possibilities, and if they had, it’s doubtful they would’ve reached the same conclusions that modern people are likely to reach about the extent of the First Amendment.

Nevertheless, it’s helpful to consider the religious context and the likely intentions of the founders in adopting the First Amendment. In 1789, a majority of the population could trace their roots to England. England had an established church. Originally, that church was Roman Catholic, and later Anglican, in the form of the Church of England. Various groups that made up the original inhabitants of the United States left England because they were persecuted by the government and the established church. This included Baptists, Puritans, and others. Virginia was primarily an Episcopalian state, and for a time it seemed Episcopalians would be Virginia’s established religion.

Baptists, Presbyterians, Moravians, and others viewed this with a degree of fear. They had not left their homes for the wilderness and fought for their freedom only to end up in the same situation they had been in England. With this brief summary of the relevant history in mind, one can see that the Establishment Clause was designed to prevent the national government, and by incorporation through the 14th Amendment, any state government, from establishing a religious sect to which all citizens were required to belong. It is worth remembering that in Europe, people who did not belong to the established religion were discriminated against in various ways. The amendment was meant to prevent that from happening.

Similarly, various religious groups who came to the United States came partly because they were restricted from exercising their religious beliefs in their country of origin. In the course of English history, for example, Puritans, Anglicans, Pilgrims, and others had been prohibited from practicing their religion/ THis was true not only in Great Britain, but in most European nations.  Put simply, the Free Exercise Clause was designed to prevent government action that would prohibit an individual from exercising their right to worship. This is the essence of the Free Exercise Clause.

The question of which kinds of state action can trigger a violation of the Establishment Clause has been a difficult one for the Court to answer. The important case of Lemon v. Kurtzman involved Pennsylvania and Rhode Island (two states with substantial Catholic populations) and programs that used taxpayer money to supplement teachers’ salaries and buy materials for teachers instructing secular subjects in private, mostly Catholic schools. The Court decided that the funding was unconstitutional because it caused excessive government entanglement with religion. In its ruling, the Court enunciated what became known as the Lemon Test. For a state program to pass muster under Lemon:

  1. The statute must have a clear secular (non-religious) purpose.
  2. The main effect of the legislation must neither advance nor inhibit religion.
  3. The legislation must not foster excessive government entanglement with religion.

As is often the case, after issuing its decision, the court faced repeated legislative attempts to finance various programs in ways that met the Lemon test. The limit test has obvious problems: any legislation with a financial effect on a group advances that group in some way, and any failure to finance it inhibits the group. Second, whether government entanglement is excessive is purely subjective and has proven impossible to apply neutrally. Ultimately, the Court abandoned the Lemon Test.[4]

The COVID-19 Cases

The Free Exercise Clause can embroil the Court in political disputes involving both religious groups and society at large. A recent example involved various states’ responses to COVID-19. The problem in these Supreme Court cases is that, while the Constitution ceded certain limited powers to the federal government, including foreign affairs and interstate commerce, all other powers not expressly given to the federal government remained with the states, including the “police power” to protect the health, safety, and morals of the people. That is why the states still have primary jurisdiction over public health. On the other hand, the First Amendment prohibits the government from limiting freedom of religion and assembly.

In Tandon v. Newsome, the Court considered whether California could enforce COVID-19 restrictions on private gatherings as applied to applicants’ at-home religious exercise.[5] The state’s restrictions on private gatherings contained “myriad exceptions and accommodations” for secular activities comparable to religious ones, triggering strict scrutiny for Free Exercise Clause violations. The Court clearly sensed that more was at stake than public health. California was using COVID-19 as a pretext to regulate religious observance.

Tandon v. Newsome was one of several cases that reached the Court on vaccinations, mask mandates, and regulating public gatherings, including religious services. The justices’ opinions naturally focused on how much deference to give to both state rules and federal mandates aimed at safeguarding public health. The decisions explored how much discretion the government should have in responding to the COVID-19 pandemic, especially given the freedoms the Constitution guarantees.

The decisions also examined the appropriate response to situations where it could be argued that religious institutions were not being treated with the same fairness afforded to other groups. Across the opinions, we see growing concern about how state restrictions might be affecting personal freedoms.[6] Personally, I feel the Court ultimately believed that states like California and New York went too far in restricting religious liberty, especially given the public debate over whether mass immunization, mask mandates, and the closure of public facilities were in fact successful in controlling the disease.

It is concerning that the Court’s COVID-19 decisions were decided almost entirely along a divide between the more liberal members, who backed state regulation in the name of religious freedom, and the more conservative members, who were more sensitive to individual rights. These decisions illustrate the growing division between those who believe the Constitution has an original meaning that can be determined from its text and by examining sources, and those members of the Court who believe the Court can interpret the Constitution as it sees fit under Living Constitution theory. The growth of the power and influence of the Federal government, and the concomitant growth of the willingness of secular members of the Court to allow infringement on religious liberties, should be a matter of concern across the religious divide in America.

Conclusion

This week ends with COVID-19 cases that highlight two sad truths about our current situation. First, tension always exists between different freedoms and societal needs. During COVID-19, for instance, people debated religious freedom versus government health mandates. This shows why wise leadership matters—some mandates have proven ineffective or even unwise. We need both elected and appointed leaders who love people, have broad experience, and use common sense. Second, religious communities must remember that religious freedom isn’t absolute and must sometimes give way to other urgent public demands. Whether we agree with how things were handled during the COVID crisis or not, the reality is that both the national government and the states had a responsibility to act, whether or not their actions were wise. Third, unfortunately, the COVID cases demonstrate the deep division in our politics. During the various COVID-19 proceedings, the Supreme Court’s composition changed, and so did its legal rulings in this area. Some people applauded that change; others were horrified.

A nation that does not seek to solve problems wisely and with compassion for all sides of pubic disputes, overreacts, and demonizes those who disagree is unlikely to survive over the long run. The First Amendment is one area where the growth of a radical secular component in our society, and a misunderstanding of what the “Separation of Church and State” actually entails, has caused, and continues to cause, issues within our political community. Next week, I intend to examine three theories the Supreme Court has used to interpret the Establishment Clause, and how it has been misapplied and misunderstood.

Copyright 2026, G. Christopher Scruggs, All Rights Reserved

[1] US Constitution, Amendment 1.

[2] Cantwell v Connecticut, 310 U.S. 296 (1940); Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1 (1947).

[3] Sarah Skeire, “George Washington’s Letter to the Jews” (September 20, 2016), https://fee.org/articles/george-washingtons-letter-to-the-jews/?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21607921915&gbraid=0AAAAADkIVmffqZzOoTPuNW13gUUsJ_YUN&gclid=CjwKCAjwoaLWBhAWEiwAnyitu4Tq6tkf9t6Yp6bR0UqW3rqN1OzHzGNPD2lX2wfYlre9tAiBztduixoCnFcQAvD_BwE, downloaded October 9, 2026).

4 Kennedy v Bremerton School District, 597 U.S. 507 (2022) held that the free exercise and free speech clauses of the First Amendment protect an individual engaging in a personal religious observance from government reprisal; the Constitution neither mandates nor permits the government to suppress such religious expression. In my view, this case is a good example of unnecessarily overturning a precedent. A dissenting opinion argued that the action had the implicit effect of establishing a religion since it was a coach praying. Nevertheless, it would’ have been possible to decide the decision on the narrow ground that the First Amendment right involved was absolute, notwithstanding any risk of establishing a religion, which was slight, at best.

[5] Tandon v. Newsome, 593 U.S. 61, 141 S. Ct. 1294 (2021). It should be noted that the case involved the

[6] For an exhaustive review of the cases in view of the entire history through similar and distinguishable emergencies, see Timothy C. MacDonnell, “The Supreme Court Du9ng Covid19: Keeping its Head When Those About It Were Losing Theirs” 79 South Dakota Law Review (2025) found at Washington and Lee University School of Law Scholarly Commons https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1884&context=wlufac, downloaded October 6, 2026.

Five Essential Freedoms No. 1: Freedom of Speech Introduced

When the Constitution was adopted, a few states hesitated to ratify it unless it included a Bill of Rights. Thomas Jefferson, for instance, believed it was a mistake not to add a Bill of Rights from the start. Overall, those wary of a powerful national government felt that a Bill of Rights was important. In the end, those who felt a Bill of Rights was needed prevailed.

Justice Story, in his Commentaries, put it this way:

It has been already stated, that many objections were taken to the constitution, not only on account of its actual provisions, but also on account of its deficiencies and omissions. Among the latter, none were proclaimed with more zeal, and pressed with more effect, than the want of a bill of rights. This, it was said, was a fatal defect; and sufficient of itself to bring on the ruin of the republic.2 To this objection several answers were given; first, that the constitution did in fact contain many provisions in the nature of a bill of rights, if the whole constitution was not in fact a bill of rights; secondly, that a bill of rights was in its nature more adapted to a monarchy, than to a government, professedly founded upon the will of the people, and executed by their immediate representatives and agents; and, thirdly, that a formal bill of rights, beyond what was contained in it, was wholly unnecessary, and might even be dangerous.[1]

Jefferson was serving as ambassador to France when the Constitution was drafted and debated, but the language of the First Amendment can be traced directly to the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, which Jefferson wrote. James Madison drafted an initial version of the speech and press clauses, which was introduced in the House of Representatives on June 8, 1789. After some rewriting and expansion by the House and Senate, the Amendment was adopted with almost no opposition.

The First Amendment to the Constitution provides that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.” The amendment protects five freedoms: religion, speech, the press, public assembly, and petitioning the government for a redress of grievances. These five freedoms form the foundation of our Constitutional system of government. Although religion is first among the five, I chose to start this series of blogs with freedom of speech.

Throughout most of our nation’s history, the First Amendment has been a cornerstone of American democracy, cherished for protecting our fundamental freedoms. Recently, however, the intellectual landscape has shifted. The rise of a nearly unregulated Internet and media space, the challenges traditional media giants face in maintaining control, and the changing influence of political elites have sparked new debates about the First Amendment. Many voices are now calling for increased regulation. As I’ve discussed before in these blogs, the First Amendment has been interpreted to include the right of corporations and others to make campaign contributions, a decision many believe was mistaken.[2] Across the political spectrum, many people believe this was a significant mistake and that it’s time to revisit what free speech really means.

The Colonial and European Experience

It is sometimes difficult for Americans to remember that freedom of speech was not universal, or even common, throughout most of human history. The Founders, for example, knew that seditious libel (criticizing the government) was a crime in England. Generally speaking, the king, and today the government, was beyond public criticism, and one had to be careful about what was said or written in public. The American colonists were familiar with these laws, and many came to America to escape them. In some respects, the First Amendment was intended to eliminate seditious libel from the American continent.

American media companies also enjoyed a kind of press freedom unknown in Europe when America was formed. Generally speaking, it required a license from the government to run a newspaper. These licenses were designed to prevent criticism of the ruling party, usually a king. Another reason for the First Amendment was to prohibit this kind of governmental restriction on the press.

In Whitney v. California, Justice Brandeis eloquently defended the reasons for the First Amendment:

Those who won our independence believed that the final end of the State was to make men free to develop their faculties, and that, in its government, the deliberative forces should prevail over the arbitrary. They valued liberty both as an end, and as a means. They believed liberty to be the secret of happiness, and courage to be the secret of liberty. They believed that freedom to think as you will and to speak as you think are means indispensable to the discovery and spread of political truth; that, without free speech and assembly, discussion would be futile; that, with them, discussion affords ordinarily adequate protection against the dissemination of noxious doctrine; that the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people; that public discussion is a political duty, and that this should be a fundamental principle of the American government. They recognized the risks to which all human institutions are subject. But they knew that order cannot be secured merely through fear of punishment for its infraction; that it is hazardous to discourage thought, hope and imagination; that fear breeds repression; that repression breeds hate; that hate menaces stable government; that the path of safety lies in the opportunity to discuss freely supposed grievances and proposed remedies, and that the fitting remedy for evil counsels is good ones. Believing in the power of reason as applied through public discussion, they eschewed silence coerced by law — the argument of force in its worst form. Recognizing the occasional tyrannies of governing majorities, they amended the Constitution so that free speech and assembly should be guaranteed.[3]

In this passage, Justice Brandeis outlines the reasons why the founders felt that the amendment was necessary:

  1. To create the conditions in which human beings can flourish.
  2. To create a society based on discussion and dialogue rather than brute force.
  3. To protect fundamental human freedoms, even though contract theory gave the state certain powers.
  4. To create a public forum where political truth could be discovered and acted upon by those in authority.
  5. To guarantee the right of like-minded people to gather together without interference by the state.
  6. To create a stable government based on the rights of those who feel wronged to make public their disagreements with prevailing wisdom.
  7. To protect minorities against the tyranny of majority views, thus allowing unpopular views that may ultimately be proven true to have a place in the public forum.

Justice Brandeis’ list of reasons for the amendment shows that the amendment’s main purpose was to safeguard certain basic human freedoms, including freedom of political speech. However, the Court has also protected other types of speech. Not everyone agrees with this view. For example, Judge Robert Bork believed only political speech deserved First Amendment protection, and he felt the court shouldn’t expand that protection beyond the right to oppose the government and other parties’ political views.[4]

Limits on the Right

From the start, people understood that freedom of Speech was important. However, they also knew it would probably have limits because of real-world practicalities. As Justice Story put it,

The next clause of the amendment respects the liberty of the press. “Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.” That this amendment was intended to secure to every citizen an absolute right to speak, or write, or print, whatever he might please, without any responsibility, public or private, therefor, is a supposition too wild to be indulged by any rational man. This would be to allow to every citizen a right to destroy, at his pleasure, the reputation, the peace, the property, and even the personal safety of every other citizen. A man might, out of mere malice and revenge, accuse another of the most infamous crimes; might excite against him the indignation of all his fellow citizens by the most atrocious calumnies; might disturb, nay, overturn all his domestic peace, and embitter his parental affections; might inflict the most distressing punishments upon the weak, the timid, and the innocent; might prejudice all a man’s civil, and political, and private rights; and might stir up sedition, rebellion, and treason even against the government itself, in the wantonness of his passions, or the corruption of his heart. Civil society could not go on under such circumstances. Men would then be obliged to resort to private vengeance, to make up for the deficiencies of the law; and assassinations, and savage cruelties, would be perpetrated with all the frequency belonging to barbarous and brutal communities. It is plum, then, that the language of this amendment imports no more, than that every man shall have a right to speak, write, and print his opinions upon any subject whatsoever, without any prior restraint, so always, that he does not injure any other person in his rights, person, property, or reputation; and so always, that he does not thereby disturb the public peace, or attempt to subvert the government. It is neither more nor less, than an expansion of the great doctrine, recently brought into operation in the law of libel, that every man shall be at liberty to publish what is true, with good motives and for justifiable ends. And with this reasonable limitation it is not only right in itself, but it is an inestimable privilege in a free government. Without such a limitation, it might become the scourge of the republic, first denouncing the principles of liberty, and then, by rendering the most virtuous patriots odious through the terrors of the press, introducing despotism in its worst form.[5]

Story understands that freedom of speech cannot be absolute and does not give people the right to use public speech to defame character, exact private vengeance, or undermine another person’s life. Consistent with those who believe the original intent was limited, Story limits the right to express one’s opinion on matters of public importance without prior restraint, so long as it does not injure another person’s reputation. It does not give the right to disturb the peace or subvert good government. It is a liberty to publish what is true in a way that does not injure other people. Nevertheless, the Court has granted great leeway in interpreting the text and, in many ways, has expanded the right beyond the mirror, protecting political speech.

Justice Story ends his analysis with a warning that is important in this particular moment in history: without limitations on this right that prevent liable, deliberate statements of fact and the undermining of the constitutional form of government we have, the amendment becomes a tool for those who would incite violence or overthrow our freedoms. One can make a fairly good case that we are at a moment in which the enemies of freedom are using the Constitution for a purpose it never had.

Conclusion

While the idea of absolute free speech can be quite appealing, it’s important to recognize that in reality, some boundaries are necessary to prevent harm to others. Finding a balance is tricky, especially when considering whether restrictions should only apply to political speech. For example, it’s often challenging to draw the line between political expression and artistic expression. Even if placing a Cross in a glass of urine seems offensive and culturally provocative, an artist might argue that it’s a way to comment on the influence of Christian faith on American society and politics. This example shows how a matter of free expression can sometimes be framed as a political speech issue. That’s why the Supreme Court has interpreted the First Amendment more broadly, protecting not just political speech but a wide range of expressive activities.[6]

Despite the need for protections against the misuse of the First Amendment, it’s important to recognize its centrality in our political system. Current attempts to limit freedom of speech and censor views that dominant groups deem inadequate directly threaten our democratic system. It should be obvious, but those in power decide when to use the courts to limit speech, and they use them to protect their own positions and authority.

On the other side of the equation, it has long been recognized that the First Amendment should not be used as a cover for brutality, slander, and the destruction of people with whom you disagree, among other aspects of what I have called “politics as war.” The public arena can become a place of unmitigated, unrestrained speech with very little rational content. One need only look at the comment sections of many social media sites to see how often responses are nothing more than cursing or screaming in print. Our constitutional system was not designed to protect the public from their own base instincts.

Copyright 2026, G. Christopher Scruggs, All Rights Reserved

1 Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the U.S. (1833), Sec. 1852, 830 found at Story: Commentaries on the Constitution of the U.S. (1833) Page 837 © Copyright 2003, 2005 Lonang Institute (downloaded July 27, 2026), hereafter “Story.” I have not modernized Story’s language, which can be fairly cumbersome and difficult to understand. He wrote in another era.

[2] Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 US 310 (2010).

[3] Whitney v. California, 274 US 357 (1927), 375-376 (Justice Brandeis concurring).

[4] Robert Bork, Neutral Principles and Some First Amendment Problems, 47 Ind. L.J.1, 28 (1971).

[5] Story, Section 1874, at 837.

[6] Erin Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law: Principles and Policies 3rd ed (New York, NY: Aspen Publishers, 2006), 927. This book has been an important source on this issue and will remain so in future blogs.